Bioquímica cerebral
1H Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) assessment of the effects of Eicosapentaenoic-Docosahexaenoic Acids and Choline-Inositol supplementation on Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)
Discussion
The previously
shown results suggest an increase in the resonance intensity of Choline-containing
compounds on ADHD-children after 6-month treatment with oral supplementation
of EPA-DHA and CHO/INO. Choline is the precursor of acetylcholine and phosphatidylcholine.
Mainly obtained from the diet, Choline constitutes a crucial intermediate in
several clinically relevant neurochemical processes. Studies performed on animals
demonstrate an increase of Choline metabolites in their brains after oral administration
(50-51) . Quite a few MRS reports differ from finding similar increases in human
subjects (52-57). In this study, choline-containing compounds in human brain
(phosphocholine, glycerol-phosphocholine and choline) were MRS-measured before
and after the ingestion of 50 mg/Kg Choline Bitartrate-Inositol in forty ADHD-children.
Cho/Cr ratios
obtained were compared and referred to HR?s basal ganglia Cho/Cr ratios.
Substantial and remarkably similar increases in the brain choline resonance
occurred, with a nearly 22% rise in the choline resonance observed in ADHD-children
(Case No 5 reported in sequence on Figures 2, 3 and 4) after oral supplementation
(p < 0.05 versus baseline). Our data agrees on other authors? reports
on the increase of brain Choline levels after Choline ingestion (52-55). Choline
metabolites decrease has been observed in basal ganglia, as an age related process
(58), and in psychiatric conditions, in which basal ganglia are involved (59).
Cho/Cr increased-ratio corresponded with the improvement of the clinical signs
of ADHD.
Spearman
correlation coefficient shows significant statistical association (p<0.05)
between the improvement in cognitive abilities of ADHD-children (Verbal/Performance
Scales as measured by Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised and Visual-motor
functioning / Visual-perceptual skills measured by Bender-Gestalt test) and
a raise in Cho/Cr ratio. However, our results could be explained on the basis
of positive interactions between CHO/INO and EPA/DHA simultaneous administration.
The beneficial
effects of LCPUFA on ADHD have been brought into focus in the last years. The
consistent findings of both clinical signs of fatty acid deficiency and blood
biochemical indices of fatty acid abnormalities in a subset of ADHD-children
indicate that supplementation with LCPUFA might be helpful in the management
of this condition in, at least, some cases. Now, the challenge is to determine
what proportion of diagnosed ADHD-children might benefit from such supplementation,
and how they may be well identified. Only a few pilot studies about gamma linoleic
acid?s deficiency effects on ADHD have been published.
Two double-blind
placebo-controlled trials of gamma linoleic acid (GLA) supplementation gave
equivocal results in ADHD-subjects who weren?t selected as having low
levels of n-6 fatty acids (60-61). The second study reported modest benefits
for GLA supplementation over placebo, although it was less effective than D-amphetamine
(61). In addition, the level of serum triglyceride GLA found correlated inversely
with Conners? scale scores (62). The GLA?s modest benefit is unsurprising.
Evidence gathered since then suggests that n-3 rather than n-6 fatty acid deficiency
may be more relevant in ADHD. The design of this study and its treatment duration
cannot be considered appropriate for the evaluation of fatty acid treatment
because second study-subjects were randomly allocated to GLA, D-amphetamine
or placebo for 1 month each.
Unlike D-amphetamine,
fatty acids cannot be expected to act rapidly for changing symptoms or behavior.
Rather, recent evidence has shown that LCPUFA levels in the brain may take up
to 3 months to recover from a chronic deficiency state (63-64) and this must,
therefore, be regarded as an essential consideration in the design of future
treatment studies. A published report on the results from a random, double-blind
treatment trial on ADHD-children with clinical signs of fatty acid?s deficiency
(65) showed its authors? findings that combined-supplementation of DHA,
EPA, AA and DGLA (weighted in favor of the n-3 fatty acids) was successful in
changing the blood fatty acid profile of ADHD-children. These changes were associated
with reductions in ADHD symptoms. In fact, DHA alone may be, indeed, ineffective
as other fatty acids (EPA) may account for the benefits detected (65).
The differences
could be on the basis of subject selection. Further studies are required to
determine if the Choline signals raise that we observed is related to the pharmacological
combination used, which may suggest a possible increase either in the brain
uptake or in the bioavailability of Choline due to EPA/DHA coadministration.
Stoll?s data from unstable bipolar disorder patients treated with high-dose
omega-3 fatty acid supplementation, previously treated with Choline to attenuate
cell signaling through the phosphatidylcholine system (66), agrees on our findings.
The biochemical basis that could possibly support this hypothesis is the evidence
that omega-3 fatty acids can also inhibit hydrolysis of membrane phospholipids,
such as phosphatidylinositol, and may thus inhibit receptor-linked G-protein
signal transduction (66). On the other hand, phosphatidylcholine is also effective
in protecting DHA/EPA from free radical oxidative stress. Inositol is a simple
polyol precursor in a second messenger system important in the brain. Cerebrospinal
fluid Inositol decrease has been reported on depression. Inositol clinically
controlled trials are few for patients with depression, panic disorder, and
obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) (67-70). Positive psychoactive effects on
animals (71) clearly strengthen the necessity of further clinical trials and
Inositol?s potential for general therapeutic use in humans. The possibility
of a pharmacological synergism between EPA/DHA, Choline and Inositol on ADHD
is already open for further studies.
In conclusion,
MRS may provide a useful tool for monitoring ADHD-childrenís response
to nutritional medicine. The link between MRS-based EPA/DHA and CHO/INO monitoring
and the improvement of the numerical, verbal, visual, hearing and concentration
capacities may also offer a fertile ground for developing an EPA/DHA plus CHO/INO
based supplementation therapy and predicting its efficacy to upgrade ADHD-children
cognitive abilities. |